Algodoo

Oh, and here are reasons:
12th Orange (Not many know him, and from what I know, he is quite new.)

11th Sky (Yeah... Really bad at challenges, he had to be eliminated.)

10th Magenta (Who is this person? Also, he/she will be oout because of the undying magenta hatred... STAP THE HATING!)

9th Red (Again, who is this? He also did not do well in challenges nor did he do most of them.)

Purple is moved to The Awesome Navies to balance teams out.

8th Blue (Well, he made a team name that SOMEHOW was better than mine, and he was a threat with many powerful tokens.)

7th Lime (Lime did... Ok in challenges. But he was mostly offline.)

MERGE!

6th Yellow (Yellow did great in challenges, but was a threat.)

5th Purple (Was always doing challenges, but the 2 others UFE (Ryan and Macky) had used their tokens, so Purple was eliminated.)

4th Navy (A awesome player, and at the merge, joined my and black's allience, so he got really far because of this.)

3rd Green (Green is pretty popular, and was a pretty great contestant. He did challenges pretty often, and was very good at them.)

2nd Cyan (Me) or Black (Either way, I could not decide which one of us would win! We are online everyday, and we are awesome at challenges! But, Black deserves it, since he deserves to win, being a awesome contestant)

1st Black or Cyan (Me) (Same Reason as 2nd.)

Yeah... I registered 3 months ago...

Quality - 10/10 - COOL!
No commenting - 3/3
Earliness - 6/7 - A bit too late to be considered early. A BIT.

Total - 19/20!